Moody's downgrades S&P (well, its parent company anyway)

The credit ratings agency famous for downgrading the credit ratings of sovereign nations, Moody's, has decided to downgrade the parent company of its main competitor in the 'ratings agencies' market.

by Michael Northcott
Last Updated: 19 Aug 2013

In what could be interpreted as something of a childish move, Moody’s has decided to downgrade the debt rating on McGraw Hill - which owns Moody's arch rival Standard & Poor's - two levels from Baa2 to A3, and stuck its rating outlook on negative. That means it is likely to get even worse in the foreseeable future.

Why have they done such a thing, we hear you ask? OK, we’ll come clean. It isn’t just infantile point scoring: there are a couple of big-boy issues that it is dealing with. 

First, the US government has filed a lawsuit seeking around $5bn in damages against McGraw Hill, claiming that S&P refused to warn investors that the housing market was on the verge of collapse back in 2006. The government says the ratings agency kept it under wraps because it thought revealing the news would be bad for business.

Second, punters are expecting a big loss of earnings and perceived lack of ‘business diversity’, which will come from McGraw-Hill selling its education division for $2.5bn. 

In a statement, S&P has rejected the US government’s case, saying: ‘Hindsight is no basis to take legal action against the good faith opinions of professionals. Claims that we deliberately kept ratings high when we knew they should be lower are simply not true.’

Shares in McGraw-Hill indicate that investors aren’t convinced, however. The share price has fallen 22% in February alone. If things get any worse, that credit rating won’t be far wrong anyway…

Find this article useful?

Get more great articles like this in your inbox every lunchtime

Upcoming Events

Latest on MT

'Don't be governed by risk' - Pitcher & Piano founder Crispin Tweddell's start-up cocktail

'Don't be governed by risk' - Pitcher & Piano founder Crispin Tweddell's start-up cocktail

The entrepreneur-turned-investor shares his recipe for success - know your customer and be ready to take a chance.

How Mike Ashley can fix Sports Direct's reputation

How Mike Ashley can fix Sports Direct's reputation

His company's name has been well and truly sullied, but Mike Ashley still has the chance to reform it, through transparency.

Get ready for the 'Lego' organization

Get ready for the 'Lego' organization

In a rapidly changing world, businesses will become amalgams of building blocks that come together for specific purposes.

Do you believe Elon Musk's vision of the future?

Do you believe Elon Musk's vision of the future?

The Tesla entrepreneur's 'Master Plan, Part Deux' could bring him up against Uber in the driverless ride-hailing market.

Corbyn wants small firms to report their gender pay gap too

Corbyn wants small firms to report their gender pay gap too

The Labour leader has launched his re-election campaign with plans to tackle discrimination.

Why social enterprises shouldn't consider profit a dirty word

Why social enterprises shouldn't consider profit a dirty word

Doing good and making a bundle aren't incompatible, writes Rhea Silva.