Why ditching appraisals is a stupid idea

The HR fad for scrapping performance reviews won't benefit either employers or employees.

by Tomas Chamorro-Premuzic
Last Updated: 28 Oct 2015

The past few months have seen a great deal of discussion about the uselessness of performance evaluations.The Wall Street Journal and The New York Times, a cover feature in Harvard Business Review, and a global PR campaign by Accenture - the most prominent corporation to announce they have ditched annual performance evaluations - all suggest that organisations are ready to stop judging what employees do (and don't). But is there a clear rationale for this latest HR fad? Is it simply a populist PR move - surely most employees like the idea that they won't be evaluated any more, not least because they are coasting or slacking in their jobs - or the next stage in scientific management?

On the one hand, firms could be forgiven for eliminating appraisals. The main reason is that most of them are indeed rather pointless: they are subjective, political and rarely based on reliable data; and few managers are willing or able to provide what employees need the most, which is negative feedback. On the other hand, completely scrapping them isn't the solution.

First, in any organisation performance reflects a Pareto effect, whereby 20% of the workforce accounts for 80% of productivity. Ignoring who the 20% are, or being unable to distinguish between them and the rest, will alienate and repel talent. Second, performance evaluations are the best way to set compensation, bonuses and rewards, and most employees agree with this. Third, unless employees are provided with feedback, they will have no idea of how to get better. Self-assessments don't work because most people think they are better than they actually are, and this affects how they evaluate their performance at work.

Fortunately, there is no reason to take this HR fad seriously. As a matter of fact, the most common argument for ditching appraisals is to replace them with some form of data or talent analytics. That is, the idea that if we can put in place monitoring systems that track employees' behaviours and link them to organisational outcomes, would make human judgments of employees' performance irrelevant. But only because more objective metrics are used in lieu. So, if the goal is to make appraisals more data-driven and accurate, bring it on. Let's not forget, though, that sharing this data with employees is as important as gathering it.

Dr Tomas Chamorro-Premuzic is an international authority in psychological profiling, people analytics, and talent management. He is the CEO of Hogan Assessments and professor of business psychology at University College London and Columbia University. Follow Professor Chamorro-Premuzic on Twitter: @drtcp

Find this article useful?

Get more great articles like this in your inbox every lunchtime

Upcoming Events

Latest on MT

'Don't be governed by risk' - Pitcher & Piano founder Crispin Tweddell's start-up cocktail

'Don't be governed by risk' - Pitcher & Piano founder Crispin Tweddell's start-up cocktail

The entrepreneur-turned-investor shares his recipe for success - know your customer and be ready to take a chance.

How Mike Ashley can fix Sports Direct's reputation

How Mike Ashley can fix Sports Direct's reputation

His company's name has been well and truly sullied, but Mike Ashley still has the chance to reform it, through transparency.

Get ready for the 'Lego' organization

Get ready for the 'Lego' organization

In a rapidly changing world, businesses will become amalgams of building blocks that come together for specific purposes.

Do you believe Elon Musk's vision of the future?

Do you believe Elon Musk's vision of the future?

The Tesla entrepreneur's 'Master Plan, Part Deux' could bring him up against Uber in the driverless ride-hailing market.

Corbyn wants small firms to report their gender pay gap too

Corbyn wants small firms to report their gender pay gap too

The Labour leader has launched his re-election campaign with plans to tackle discrimination.

Why social enterprises shouldn't consider profit a dirty word

Why social enterprises shouldn't consider profit a dirty word

Doing good and making a bundle aren't incompatible, writes Rhea Silva.