Customer loyalty is a myth - success is down to how useful you are

Repeat business is less about fanatical followers and more about striving to give people what they want, says John Sills

by John Sills
Last Updated: 01 Jun 2016

I’ve started to dread the beginning of a new football season. Not because, as an Arsenal fan, I have to steel myself for the inevitable hope-to-despair cycle that will play out over the following nine months. Worse than that, it means I have to prepare for another contract negotiation with my Broadband and TV provider of choice.

Every year we go through the same merry dance, debating prices and packages until I end up with what I already had for about the same price as I was paying before. And because I’ve been doing this dance with them for many years, I’m sure they see me as a ‘loyal’ customer.  

But in reality, I don’t stay with them because I’m loyal. I stay with them because they’re useful.  And as soon as they stop being useful, or an alternative comes along that can persuade me that they can be more useful, I’ll leave.  

That’s why customer loyalty is a myth.

In today’s world, dominated by the app economy, there’s always an alternative provider just a tap away. This makes it easier than ever to switch services and fight against the customer inertia that banks, broadband providers, and other big businesses have relied upon for decades.

Woolworths, Kodak, and Blockbuster were all well-established institutions, much loved by the general public with healthy businesses and useful products and services. But as soon as the price changed, the location moved, or the need for their products diminished, customers trampled over each other to switch allegiances to the next most useful fulfiller-of-needs, stopping only to swap memories withtheir friends about misspent childhoods in the pick-and-mix aisle.

More evidence of this focus on usefulness can be seen throughout December, as people stumble out of Christmas parties looking for a way to get home quickly. Many will grab their phone and order an Uber, but not because they don’t like Black Cabs anymore, or because they don’t value The Knowledge. Instead, it’s because Uber, with it’s one-tap ordering and frictionless, cashless payment system, has become far more useful than standing in the rain, waiting for an available car, and stopping at a cash machine when the fare outweighs the non-chocolate money in their bag.

In fact, if anything, the phrase ‘customer loyalty’ should be turned the other way around – it’s more about companies staying loyal to customers than vice versa. They need to be better at keeping their promises (not changing the T&Cs mid-term), being fair (no more ‘new customer only’ deals), and showing understanding when mistakes happen (such as going unexpectedly overdrawn). After all, it’s the companies that rely on the customers to keep their businesses going – and those customers have a lot potential suitors for their hard-earned cash.

Of course, individual loyalty does exist in many other areas of life. People are incredibly loyal to their friends and family, as well as staying true to their choice of newspaper, political party, and sports team. Seeing fans collecting coins in buckets to stave off administration has become a regular sight at lower-league football clubs in the past few years, but I don’t recall seeing crowds campaigning outside of Woolworths’ Head Office when it was on the verge of collapse.

These relationships are built on something far deeper than the occasional purchase and pleasant conversation, relying on a shared sense of purpose, belonging, or values about what’s important in life. So perhaps engendering real loyalty from customers relies on the company not just staying useful, but knowing and being able to articulate its reason for being, and connecting with customers who have the same beliefs.

Customer loyalty as we know it is a myth. But those companies that focus on staying useful, being loyal, and sharing a unified cause with their customers will be the ones that they’ll recommend to their friends – regardless of whether they get reward points to spend on Crackers and Cranberries this Christmas.

John Sills is a Senior Consultant at The Foundation (@johnJsills/ @FoundationThink)

Find this article useful?

Get more great articles like this in your inbox every lunchtime

Upcoming Events

Latest on MT

The reason women are less likely to get graduate jobs

The reason women are less likely to get graduate jobs

Despite the high priority employers give to diversity, the gender gap in graduate recruitment persists.

Why Philip Green's savaged reputation matters

Why Philip Green's savaged reputation matters

The retail tycoon is still rolling in wealth but his public image could be problematic - and what about that knighthood?

Only 'radical honesty' can rebuild trust in business, and save us from Green and Trump

Only 'radical honesty' can rebuild trust in business, and save us from Green and Trump

Philip Green and Donald Trump are harbingers of a post-trust future that can only be avoided by a progressive revolution in business leadership.

'Don't be governed by risk' - Pitcher & Piano founder Crispin Tweddell's start-up cocktail

'Don't be governed by risk' - Pitcher & Piano founder Crispin Tweddell's start-up cocktail

The entrepreneur-turned-investor shares his recipe for success - know your customer and be ready to take a chance.

How Mike Ashley can fix Sports Direct's reputation

How Mike Ashley can fix Sports Direct's reputation

His company's name has been well and truly sullied, but Mike Ashley still has the chance to reform it, through transparency.

Get ready for the 'Lego' organization

Get ready for the 'Lego' organization

In a rapidly changing world, businesses will become amalgams of building blocks that come together for specific purposes.