Banks fail to come under Project Merlin's spell

Figures by the Bank of England show banks failed to meet SME lending targets. Although they might have had an invisibility cloak thrown over them by next year.

by Emma Haslett
Last Updated: 12 Aug 2011
Further confirmation today from the Bank of England that while the five banks involved in the Project Merlin deal on lending (that’s RBS, Lloyds, HSBC, Barclays and Santander) managed to near enough meet their lending targets when it came to big business, their small business lending failed to measure up. As expected, half-year figures published this morning showed that of the £38bn they were supposed to have loaned to small businesses over the first six months of the year, they only managed to provide £37.3bn worth of borrowing. Not a particularly impressive start.

The banks’ age-old argument may be that there isn’t enough demand for loans among SMEs, but a survey we covered earlier this week suggests otherwise: according to figures by comparison site Make It Cheaper, almost half of entrepreneurs have had to turn to alternative sources of funding to help keep their business afloat. Just over a quarter had to turn to family and friends, while 13% even went as far as to remortgage their house.

So banks’ excuses are beginning to sound a bit lame. Particularly when you take into account a report by Sky News’ Mark Kleinman, who says he’s discovered banks will be doing all they can to avoid another deal like Merlin next year. Apparently, the five banks which took part in this year’s agreement have got together to ‘map out a united position’ to take on the Government if it tries to persuade them to go ahead with another deal, on the grounds that it’s ‘anti-competitive’.

Apparently, the banks’ main objections are to the extra agreements they had to make as part of Project Merlin – a one-off contribution to the Big Society Bank, for example, as well as a payment to the Government’s Business Growth Fund, aimed at small businesses. They’re also none too keen on the commitments they were forced to make on bonuses, saying it makes it difficult to compete with US and European rivals.

But although they’re willing to accept that in all likelihood, they’ll still have to make lending commitments, banking bosses are reportedly not happy about it. Stuart Gulliver, the CEO of HSBC, reportedly told Kleinman that lending targets are ‘dangerous’ and risk triggering a surge in bad loans, while another (anonymous) banking chief said: ‘My sense is that there would be little desire to repeat it from any of the participants.’

No decision will be made until after the Independent Commission on Banking’s final recommendations are published in mid-September. So let’s hope they’ve got something persuasive up their wizard’s sleeve…

Find this article useful?

Get more great articles like this in your inbox every lunchtime

Upcoming Events

Subscribe

Get your essential reading delivered. Subscribe to Management Today