BHS bust-up leaves Philip Green's reputation in the balance

The retail tycoon will have an uphill struggle when he goes before MPs next week.

by Jack Torrance
Last Updated: 20 Aug 2020

Yesterday’s business select committee hearing went better than expected for Sports Direct boss Mike Ashley, but it's already not looking good for Philip Green, who is due to appear next week. Today former BHS bosses and those who bought the chain from Green last year appeared before the committee, and the revelations and accusations about its demise were salacious to say the least.

First to face MPs were Richard Price, BHS’s former CEO, Darren Topp, its current boss, and Michael Hitchcock, who acted as its de facto finance director. Most of their ire was aimed at Dominic Chappell, the former racing driver who led the buyout of BHS from Green last year. Hitchcock described him as a ‘Premier League liar’ and a ‘mythomaniac.’ Topp accused Chappell of threatening to kill him for raising concerns about a transfer of cash out of the company (something Chappell later denied). None of that reflected well on Chappell but it also reinforces the argument that in dealing with him, Green’s judgment was poor.  

Much of the rest of the session got bogged down in the he said, she said of BHS’s byzantine property deals as MPs grilled former directors of Retail Acquisitions Limited and then Chappell himself. The latter laid into Green, accusing him of forcing the chain’s closure and even threatening to sue him. BHS could have been acquired by Ashley's Sports Direct, Chappell suggested, but Green apparently prevented that from happening, favouring bringing in the administrators instead. 

Green wasn’t exactly seen as a virtuous hero of British business, having already been labelled the 'unacceptable face of capitalism' by MPs over the chain's collapse. Now the full gory details are beginning to emerge things are looking even worse. He will need to put in a pretty stunning performance next week if he has any hope of salvaging his situation. 

Find this article useful?

Get more great articles like this in your inbox every lunchtime

How to compete with Amazon's rapid growth has led to an earlier-than-anticipated UK expansion.

Do Myers-Briggs tests actually work?

The personality profiles are widely used by HR departments the world over, but psychologists aren’t...

"One of the biggest faults of the European ecosystem is founders sell out ...

Management Today meets Perlego founder Gauthier Van Malderen.

How CEOs can improve sales

“Hitting those sales targets no longer sits with sales teams, instead it should start and...

Tony Soprano & how leaders get trapped in bubbles

Beware people telling you what you want to hear, say the MD of Merryck &...

Micro-breaks improve performance

Managers should take a more relaxed approach to tired team members, according to a study....