Gas prices were rigged, claims whistleblower

UK regulators are investigating some 'unusual' natural gas trades that took place in September. Wholesale gas prices were fixed, just like Libor, alleges a whistleblower.

by Rebecca Burn-Callander
Last Updated: 19 Aug 2013

Something is rotten in the state of utility companies. Yesterday, several water firms were embroiled in a tax avoidance scandal, and today natural gas is feeling the heat.  Today’s furore has arisen from a statement from Seth Freedman, a former employee at ICIS Heron, which publishes energy price reports based on financial data from traders on the ground. According to his testimony to the FSA, these natural gas traders were regularly feeding his company –and others like it – fictitious numbers in order to inflate profits.

The actual financial jiggery pokery is a little tricky but, put simply, these traders would make smaller trades at prices below the market in order to distort the price of gas. Apparently on September 28, a number of dealers made these dodgy bids. ‘People were putting trades in at a key moment when we’re assessing the market and building our prices,’ says Freedman. ‘It was done with the explicit intention of manipulating prices, backed up with false reporting of numbers so that someone can profit.’

Sound familiar? That’s because we’ve been through all this with Libor. Much like the interbank lending rate, wholesale deals aren't brokered through a robust and transparent electronic system, but thrashed out between companies.  That makes it much easier to manipulate. And, while the natural gas market isn’t quite as hulking as the banking sector, it’s still worth around £300bn in the UK.

Energy secretary Ed Davey is taking Freedman’s claims very seriously and an inquiry has been launched. Both the FSA and Ofgem are now investigating. So far, however, there seems no evidence that consumers have been paying over the odds on gas bills. The tampering simply drove down wholesale prices in order to serve up juicy profit, leaving the retail price untouched.

If these allegations are based in fact, it could have dire consequences for some of the ‘big six’ energy firms. None have been expressly implicated in the scandal so far; four have already released statements denying any knowledge of market rigging.  Fines will be imposed if any firms are found guilty of wrongdoing, not to mention the slew of regulation that will be introduced. 

Today's revelations ultimately point to a further unravelling of privatisation of the utlities in the eighties. First trains, then water, and now gas are all slowly showing their cracks. It seems the free market can come back and bite the consumer after all...

Find this article useful?

Get more great articles like this in your inbox every lunchtime

When should you step down as CEO?

Bob Iger's departure poses an unpopular question for bosses.

The death and resurrection of the premium customer

Top-end service is no longer at the discretion of the management.

What HS2 can teach you about project failure

And how you can prevent projects going astray.

35 Women Under 35 2020: Nominations open

Management Today's 35 Women Under 35 showcases the country's rising stars in business. Here's how...

Practical steps for breaking silos

Briefing: Adam Williams, former CEO of influencer marketing agency Takumi, shares what he has learned...

The Power 50: Proof that you can be a part-time CEO

Just a few years ago, executives were reluctant to admit they worked part-time for fear...