Government mulls train network sell-off

Is more fragmentation really what Britain's railways need?

by Jack Torrance
Last Updated: 15 Feb 2016

Transport for London has announced plans to take control of London’s suburban railways and polls suggest the public are in favour of renationalising train companies. So it might be surprising to learn the government is weighing up plans to sell-off vast tranches of the nation’s rail network.

But it looks like that could be on the cards. Yesterday the Sunday Times reported that Nicola Shaw, the High Speed One boss leading a review of the network, is set to recommend that several of the UK’s rail routes be taken out of the hands of Network Rail and given to pension, insurance and sovereign wealth funds. As well a breaking up the state monopoly, Shaw is expected to propose the creation of a new agency that will be responsible for ‘strategic’ matters such as franchising, upgrades, standards and new routes.

Though Network Rail is no doubt due a kick up the behind, many will ask whether more fragmentation is really in the best interest of the public. The rationale behind TfL’s suburban rail takeover is that it will be able to provide a ‘joined up’ service where all the moving cogs work better together. There is already a disconnect between the private train operators and Network Rail; breaking the network up into different, separately run routes would surely complicate things further.

A break-up would also negate the economies of scale that Network Rail currently enjoys. ‘We currently have the buying power of a national company, and we buy millions and millions of tonnes of materials such as steel and sleepers,’ a source told the FT. ‘We would lose that if we were broken up.’

One thing’s for sure, the government is not happy to have Network Rail’s hefty £38bn worth of debt sitting on it balance sheet. And George Osborne hasn’t been shy of privatisation – he wants to get shot of Lloyds ASAP and flogged the UK's stake in Eurostar last year too. Channel 4 could also be on its way to the market soon.

We’ll get a better sense of what’s going to happen when Shaw publishes her report early next month. Any proposal for privatisation will not be taken lightly by the rail unions. Get ready to have your commute ruined by strike action.

Find this article useful?

Get more great articles like this in your inbox every lunchtime