Markets shrug as Fitch downgrades six banks

Six months ago, it would have been a disaster, but now, the markets have barely reacted. Is this the beginning of the end for ratings agencies?

by Emma Haslett
Last Updated: 16 Dec 2011

Eh up, the credit ratings agencies are at it again: this time, it’s Fitch, the smallest of the three leading agencies, which has downgraded the ratings of six of the world’s largest banks, including Bank of America, Goldman Sachs, BNP Paribas, Deutsche Bank, Credit Suisse and (most importantly, of course) Barclays. For those banks, it cut the ‘default issue ratings’, which calls into question their ability to pay debts on time – while another two, Morgan Stanley and Societe Generale, saw their viability ratings, which measures a bank’s financial strength, downgraded. Which all sounds pretty dire – so why have the markets barely flinched?

Fitch isn’t the first ratings agency to get its downgrade on in recent weeks – only last week, Moody’s wielded its sword at France’s three biggest banks (Societe Generale and BNP Paribas included). This is all because banks have been forced to take massive charges on some of the sovereign debts they’re exposed to, which has caused worries that they won’t be able to lend to each other.

In fact, in its release, Fitch was careful to note that the downgrades weren’t actually down to anything the banks themselves were doing. It warned that although banks have been busily hoarding cash to create capital buffers against another credit crisis, new regulation introduced by the EU could mean their earnings potential is restricted and the costs of lending go up. So the message is that none of this is really the banks’ faults.

No wonder, then, that the markets didn’t give more than a shrug when the news broke this morning. While European markets didn’t even fluctuate, shares in Barclays actually rose by 1.6%. As Seymour Pierce analyst Bruce Packard told the Financial Times: ‘I’m not sure how much notice equity markets take of credit ratings on banks at the moment – I don’t change my valuation model if there’s a ratings agency downgrade.’

That’s an interesting point of view, particularly as both Standard & Poor’s and Moody’s are apparently poised on the brink of downgrading France’s sovereign debt rating. That’s caused a bit of a cross-channel diplomatic incident, after French central bank governor Christian Noyer said on breakfast radio this morning that ‘they should start by downgrading the UK, which has a bigger deficit, as much debt, more inflation, weaker growth and where bank lending is collapsing’. If the markets’ reaction to the bank downgrade is anything to go by, though, it’s a moot point. It might be that ratings agencies are about to become irrelevant.

Find this article useful?

Get more great articles like this in your inbox every lunchtime

Has the cult of workplace wellbeing run its course?

Forget mindfulness apps and fresh fruit Fridays. If we really care about employee wellbeing, we...

Cybercriminals: A case study for decentralised organisations?

A study shows that stereotypes of organised criminals are wide of the mark.

Why your turnaround is failing

Be careful where you look for advice.

Crash course: How to find hidden talent

The best person for the role might be closer than you think.

What they don't tell you about flexible working

The realities of ditching the nine to five don't always live up to the hype....

The business case for compassion: Nando's, Cisco and Innocent Drinks

Consciously, systematically humane cultures reap enormous benefits, argues academic Amy Bradley.