When is it okay to lie to your employees?

“Everyone has told a white lie to their employer”, but what about vice versa?

by Orianna Rosa Royle
Last Updated: 10 Sep 2020
Also in:
Food for thought

From pulling a sickie to boasting extra years of experience on your CV, white lies in the workplace aren’t uncommon, with 44 per cent of employees lying to avoid getting into trouble according to Glassdoor research.

Between peers, lying can even keep harmony and facilitate positive interactions, like telling someone you like their haircut when really you do not. The Glassdoor research echoed this, with 69 per cent saying that it was acceptable to lie to protect someone's feelings at work. 

For managers, things get trickier. Diplomatically sparing an underperforming team member's feelings could get in the way of constructive feedback, hinder colleagues and ultimately be costly to the business. But then so could brutal honesty, which can easily batter motivation all round.

After all, complex truths rarely make good headlines. Full transparency about executive pay or bonuses, for example, can undermine solidarity. Saying 'but if I wasn't paid 50 times more than you, I'd just leave and you'd have to hire a second-rate replacement and that wouldn't help anyone' is unlikely to improve matters, even if it is what you really think. 

So when is it okay as a boss to fib to employees?

It seems the question is a sensitive one. At a time when many companies are trying to convince their people that the workplace is safe, the majority of leaders we reached out to unsurprisingly wouldn’t discuss anything that might undermine trust.

What we found, from those who did speak, is that there is no consensus:

Michael Dubicki, business development director, Flexioffices 

I think that the asking of the question is indicative of an underlying need to justify lying in a lot of cases. The simpler question would be: is it fair or necessary to lie to employees at all? I think everyone would answer “no”. If the answer to that is “no”, then the answer to the original question must be “never”. Being honest with employees is always the best policy, even if the message is difficult. COVID is a good example: I’m sure many companies would have told their employees they’d be just fine and then U-turned to make redundancies in large numbers shortly after. Why not bite the bullet straight away? Lying won’t make things any easier or change the facts. But it will hurt reputations.  

Anonymous MD

I believe everyone tells white lies, especially if you’re in a senior role and have a team underneath you. The times when you may need to lie or at least hold back from the whole truth could be for example around the status and position of the business. This could be especially if the company is failing - it's never easy to share bad news. So many things can be happening behind the scenes and by sharing any information as soon as it comes in, matters could spiral out of control - even though they might otherwise have been resolved. 

Justine Campbell, managing partner for talent, EY UK&I 

Fostering inclusive cultures has never been more important than at a time when many people are physically distanced from colleagues, leaders and the workplace due to COVID-19. Being dishonest or deliberately misleading your people should never be acceptable. Creating a culture of trust, transparency and openness is vital in business. It fosters an environment where people feel more able to ask questions, be their authentic selves, and ultimately achieve their full potential. An inclusive and honest workplace helps employees feel better connected to their peers and leaders and can also have a positive impact on mental and physical wellbeing. 

Image credit: LMPC via Getty Images

Tags:

Find this article useful?

Get more great articles like this in your inbox every lunchtime

My boss used to take credit for my work

The leader that made me: We Are Social’s Tom Bayliss had a manager who favoured...

Remote working is actually good for creativity

Productivity goes up too, but collaboration suffers, according to Management Today research.

Management advice from unusual places: Life drawing class

Learning to draw can give you perspective in more ways than one.

Should you ditch the office for a WeWork?

Business leaders say no, so Management Today finds out why the office is here to...

Does your organisation lack empathy?

Understanding others is something you can work on.

The long-term consequences of working from home

Not having to commute generally leaves workers generally happier, but there’s a darker side to...